CHAPTER 6

Friday night—the night before the wedding—was unbearable.
None of us slept.
We sat around the kitchen table, going over the plan one more time. One hundred times.
Lucy had it memorized. She had made index cards for each of us with our roles written out in her neat handwriting.
“Grandpa, you go in through the main entrance at 3:45. You’re on the guest list—Mom’s maiden name is still there. You sit in the back row. When the music starts for the processional, you pull out your phone and start recording everything.”
She turned to Rachel.
“Rachel, you and April and I will be in the bride’s dressing room. They’ll make us get into those horrible dresses. We’ll pretend to cooperate. But when the coordinator comes to get us to walk down the aisle... we don’t go. We go out the side door and around to the front of the church. We’ll meet Grandpa by the lectern.”
April raised her hand like she was in school. “Lucy? When do I give them the magic paper?”
Lucy knelt down so she was eye level with her little sister. She spoke gently, but with absolute seriousness.
“At exactly 4:02. Right after the minister says ‘Who gives this woman to be married to this man?’ That’s when you walk up the aisle. You walk right past Daddy. You don’t look at him. You walk straight to the minister. And you hand him the envelope. Can you do that, April?”
April nodded so hard her pigtails bounced. “I can do it. I promised Mommy.”
My chest ached. A six-year-old girl, entrusted with the most devastating secret of all. And she was braver than most men I knew.
At two o’clock in the morning, there was a knock on the door.
We all froze.
Lucy grabbed the nearest heavy object—a cast-iron skillet from the stove. Rachel pulled the girls behind her. I walked slowly to the door.
Through the peephole, I saw a woman. Middle-aged. Red hair. Holding a large envelope.
I recognized her. It was Margaret—Rose’s best friend since kindergarten. She had been at the funeral. She had been one of the few people who came up to me afterward and said, “Something isn’t right about this.”
I unlocked the door.
“Margaret? What are you doing here at this hour?”
She pushed past me into the house. She was out of breath, like she had run all the way.
“Charles,” she said, her eyes wide with fear, “you have to get the girls out of here. Now.”
“What’s happened?”
“Arthur,” she gasped. “I was at the bachelorette party tonight. Crystal was so drunk she couldn’t stand up. She started talking. About Rose. About how Rose was ‘in the way.’ About how Arthur ‘took care of it.’ She said they knew you had something. Evidence. She said Arthur was going to break in here tonight. Burn the house down if he had to. Make it look like an accident. He said he’d rather kill everyone in this house than let you ruin tomorrow.”
My blood turned to ice.
Lucy was standing in the kitchen doorway. She had heard everything. She was still holding the skillet.
“He’s not getting the notebook,” she said. Her voice was flat. Deadly.
Margaret held up the envelope she was carrying. “I brought this. It’s from Rose. She gave it to me two months ago. Told me to give it to you only if Arthur ever came after you. It’s the title to the house. She secretly transferred it back to her name three weeks before she died. Arthur thinks he owns it, but he doesn’t. It’s yours now. Or the girls’, rather. She also left a letter for the police. Sworn affidavit. Everything she knew. She had it notarized.”
I took the envelope. My hands were shaking again. Rose had thought of everything. Even this.
“How long do we have?” Lucy asked.
Margaret checked her watch. “Crystal said they’d be here around three. They’re waiting until the bars close so no one will notice them driving around.”
Lucy looked at the clock. 2:17.
“We don’t have time to pack everything,” she said. “We take what matters. The notebook. The tablet. The envelope. The copies. Everything else can be replaced.”
We moved faster than I thought possible.
Lucy stuffed the evidence into her backpack. Rachel grabbed April’s favorite stuffed rabbit and her own sketchbook. I put on my old army jacket with the copies sewn into the lining. Margaret called her brother, who owned a towing company.
“Bring the biggest truck you have,” she told him. “And a friend. We’re moving a family. Now.”
By 2:45, we were out of the house. We left the lights on. We left the television playing. We made it look like we were all asleep inside.
Margaret drove us to her brother’s warehouse on the edge of town. It was secure. It had cameras. It was the last place Arthur would look.
At 3:15, Margaret’s phone buzzed. It was a text from her friend who lived on my street.
Two cars just pulled up to your neighbor Charles’s house. Two men in hoodies. Look like they’re trying to get in the back.
I looked at Lucy. She was staring at her phone, watching the security camera app she had installed on our house the week before.
She held up the screen. We could see two figures in dark hoodies creeping around my backyard. One of them carried a can. Gasoline.
“They’re going to burn it down,” Rachel whispered.
“Let them,” Lucy said. Her voice was colder than I had ever heard it. “Let them think they won. Let them think everything is gone. Let them go to their wedding tomorrow believing they’re safe.”
We watched as the men broke in through the back window. We watched them move through the house, opening drawers, looking for something. We watched them pour gasoline on the furniture, on the carpets, on Rose’s old bedroom.
Then they lit a match.
The house went up like tinder.
I felt tears in my eyes. That house was where Rose had grown up. Where she had taken her first steps. Where she had brought her babies home from the hospital. Every memory I had of her was inside those walls.
Lucy put her hand on my arm.
“Mom’s not in there, Grandpa,” she said softly. “She’s in here.” She tapped her chest. “And in us. And in what we’re going to do tomorrow. They can burn the house. But they can’t burn the truth.”
The fire trucks arrived ten minutes later. By then, the roof was already collapsing.
We watched the news reports come in.
“Tragic fire in historic Savannah neighborhood. Retired librarian Charles Whitmore and his three granddaughters are believed to be inside. Authorities say it appears to be a case of faulty wiring. No foul play suspected.”
Lucy turned off the television.
“Good,” she said. “They think we’re dead. That means they won’t be looking for us tomorrow. They’ll walk right into the church believing they’ve won.”
May you like
She looked at each of us. Her sisters. Me. Margaret.
“Tomorrow,” she said, “we bury Arthur. Not with fire. With the truth.”