Chapter 3 - OLD FRIENDS, NEW LIES
The Silver Lake Diner hadn’t changed a bit since I was a kid: red vinyl booths, chrome trim, the smell of bacon and coffee thick in the air, a jukebox in the corner playing old country songs. I pushed the door open at 9:55, my eyes scanning the room—two truckers at the counter, a mom with two kids in a booth by the window, and in the very back, a woman with short red hair, a red baseball cap pulled low over her eyes, sipping black coffee. That had to be Maggie. I slid into the booth across from her, and she looked up, her eyes sharp, assessing, like she was already deciding if I was worth the risk.
“Finnley Dennis,” she said, not a question. “You look like your dad. Same jaw. Same ‘I’m about to burn this whole town down’ look in your eyes.” She pushed a manila folder across the table, her voice dropping so low I had to lean in to hear. “I was supposed to meet your dad the night they tried to kill him. Got to the house 10 minutes too late—found him on the kitchen floor, Reagan’s lipstick on a glass next to him, Carter’s empty beer bottle in the trash. They’d given him something, made his heart race, tried to make it look like a heart attack. I got him out through the back door, drove him to a clinic in the next county, kept him hidden ever since. He didn’t want to reach out to you till you were out—said if they knew he was alive, they’d kill you in prison to tie up loose ends.”
I stared at her, my throat tight. “Where is he? I need to see him.”
“Not yet,” she said, shaking her head. “They’ve got people watching every road out of town, every bus station, every motel. If you so much as get within 10 miles of where he is, they’ll find him. First, we need proof. Enough to put Reagan, Carter, and Hale away for good—for framing you, for attempted murder, for embezzling millions from the city.” She flipped open the folder, sliding a copy of the fake death certificate across the table. “This is the key. Dr. Elias Hale signed it—Carter’s old roommate, the guy who’s been writing him prescriptions for pain pills for years, the guy who owes Carter $80,000 in gambling debts. Carter didn’t just pay him to sign it. He threatened to hurt his 10-year-old daughter if he didn’t.”
Before I could say anything, the bell above the diner door jingled, and I froze—Jax Marlow, my best friend since third grade, the guy who’d been my best man at my wedding, the guy who’d visited me every month in prison for the first year, then stopped coming, walked in, his police uniform crisp, his hand resting on the gun at his hip. His eyes met mine, and for a second, I saw surprise, then guilt, then something else—relief. He walked over to the booth, ignoring Maggie’s glare, and slid in next to me, his voice low.
“I know you’re mad I stopped visiting,” he said, not waiting for me to yell. “But Reagan and Carter were watching me. They told me if I kept coming to see you, they’d plant drugs in my patrol car, get me fired, lock me up next to you. I’ve been digging into them on my own for a year—got copies of the city contracts, the kickbacks Hale’s been taking from Dennis Construction, the fake bank accounts they’ve been hiding the money in.” He pulled a USB drive out of his uniform pocket, sliding it across the table to Maggie. “Everything’s on there. Every transfer, every meeting, every text between Hale, Reagan, and Carter. I was gonna turn it over to the state police next week, but now that you’re out…”
Maggie picked up the drive, turning it over in her fingers. “You’re a cop. Why risk everything for him?”
“Because Finnley’s my brother,” Jax said, looking me dead in the eye. “And I know he didn’t steal that money. I knew it three years ago, I knew it every day he was in prison, and I’m gonna make sure every last one of the bastards who did this pays.”
May you like
For the first time since I got out of prison, I felt like I wasn’t alone. Jax had my back, Maggie had my dad’s back, and we had enough evidence between us to take down the whole rotten crew. We spent the next two hours going over the files, mapping out a plan: first, confront Dr. Hale, get him to confess on tape, then take everything to the state police, then bring my dad home. We were just packing up the papers when Jax’s radio crackled, dispatch’s voice urgent: Unit 4, respond to a two-car accident on Route 12, rollover, possible injuries. Jax stood up, grabbing his hat. “That’s my sector. I’ll call you as soon as I’m done. Meet me at my place tonight—no one will think to look for you there.”
He left the diner, and Maggie and I went our separate ways, me heading toward Jax’s house on the other side of town, her going back to her office to pull more files. I was halfway there when my phone rang, Jax’s voice tight, panicked: Finnley, don’t come to the house. My brakes went out on Route 12. I rolled the car into a ditch. They tampered with them. They know we’re working together. My blood ran cold. Are you okay? I yelled, running toward the highway. Banged up, but alive, he said. But Finnley—they’re not playing games. Next time, they won’t just cut the brakes.
