Chapter 4 - The Enemy Of My Enemy

The police arrived at the Whitmore estate forty minutes later. By then, Margaret had calmed down — or at least, she’d stopped screaming. She sat on the couch, perfectly composed again, her hair fixed, her wine stain blotted, a small, smug smile on her face like she knew something no one else did. Caleb sat beside her, his face bruised from where Ryan had slammed him into the wall, his phone still in his hand, his thumb hovering over the screen like he was waiting for a text that would make all of this go away.
The lead detective was a woman named Alvarez. Mid-forties, sharp eyes, no-nonsense, the kind of cop who’d seen every trick rich people tried to pull to get out of trouble. She listened to Ryan’s statement, watched the hospital video, looked at the spreadsheets, and then turned to Margaret.
“Mrs. Whitmore,” she said. “I’m going to need you to come down to the station with me. We have questions regarding the assault on Mrs. Claire Whitmore, the attempted kidnapping of her newborn son, and allegations of embezzlement in the amount of eighteen million dollars.”
Margaret didn’t stand. She just smiled. “Detective Alvarez. How lovely to finally meet you. I’ve heard so much about you from the mayor. We had lunch just last month, actually. He was telling me how difficult it’s been for the department with budget cuts. Such a shame. Fortunately, the Whitmore Foundation has been meaning to make a sizable donation to the police benevolent association. Five hundred thousand dollars, I believe. Earmarked specifically for your precinct.”
She paused, letting the bribe — because that’s exactly what it was — hang in the air.
“Surely we can work something out. This is all just a terrible misunderstanding. A family dispute. My daughter-in-law has been under a lot of stress since the birth. Postpartum depression, you know. Very common. She gets confused. Says things she doesn’t mean. Fabricates evidence. It’s all very sad, really.”
Detective Alvarez didn’t flinch. “Mrs. Whitmore. If you don’t stand up and put your hands behind your back in the next ten seconds, I will add resisting arrest to the list of charges. And I don’t care who you had lunch with. The mayor doesn’t run my cases. I do. Now — move.”
Margaret’s smile faltered. For the first time all night, she looked genuinely uncertain. She’d spent her whole life assuming money and connections would get her out of anything. And for forty years, she’d been right. But Detective Alvarez was not the kind of cop who could be bought. Claire had made sure of that.
Because Claire had done her research on Detective Alvarez too.
Three years earlier, Alvarez’s sister had lost her child in a custody battle with a wealthy ex-husband who’d used paid-off doctors and fake psychiatric evaluations to paint her as an unfit mother. The sister had killed herself six months later. Alvarez had been on a one-woman war against rich people who tried to steal children ever since. Claire had known that if this moment ever came, Alvarez was the only cop she could trust.
And so, when Margaret was led out of the house in handcuffs, her silk dress ruined, her hair askew, screaming that she’d have Alvarez fired, that she’d own the whole department by morning, Claire didn’t worry. She knew Margaret’s threats were empty. At least for now.
Caleb was arrested too, of course. He went quietly, his head down, already texting his lawyer. He was the kind of man who folded the second things got hard. Claire knew he’d flip on Margaret the second he was in the interrogation room. He’d tell them everything. He had no loyalty. Only self-preservation.
But as the patrol cars pulled out of the driveway, red lights flashing, Claire didn’t feel the relief she’d expected. She felt dread. Because Margaret was right about one thing: she wasn’t the only one with secrets. And she wouldn’t go down alone. She’d take as many people with her as she could.
The prediction came true faster than Claire had imagined.
By five the next morning, the first news article hit. WHITMORE MATRIARCH ARRESTED FOR ASSAULT AND EMBEZZLEMENT. DAUGHTER-IN-LAW REVEALS HIDDEN CAMERA FOOTAGE. By seven, it was the top story on every news channel in the state. By nine, reporters were camped outside the downtown penthouse, yelling questions up at the windows.
And then the other stories started. The ones Margaret had planted.
CLAIR WHITMORE’S BROTHER SERVING TEN YEARS FOR ARMED ROBBERY AND ATTEMPTED MURDER.
EXCLUSIVE: FORMER FRIENDS SAY CLAIRE BENNETT WAS “OBSESSED” WITH WEALTH AND STATUS.
PSYCHIATRIST WHO TREATED CLAIRE WHITMORE SPEAKS OUT: “SHE SHOWED CLASSIC SIGNS OF DELUSIONAL DISORDER.”
Claire stared at the last headline, her blood running cold. Psychiatrist? She’d never seen a psychiatrist in her life. Never. Not once.
She clicked the link. The article quoted a Dr. Helena Voss, a well-known psychiatrist who specialized in high-profile custody cases. Dr. Voss claimed she’d treated Claire for six months two years earlier, that Claire had exhibited “severe paranoid ideation,” “histrionic tendencies,” and “a pattern of fabricating abuse stories to gain sympathy.” The article even had copies of medical records — with Claire’s name, her date of birth, her old address.
“This is impossible,” Ryan said, reading over her shoulder. “You never saw anyone by that name. I would have known. We did our insurance paperwork together. There were never any mental health claims.”
“Margaret forged them,” Claire said, her mind racing. “She paid Dr. Voss to create a fake file. She’s been planning this for two years. Waiting for the day she needed to prove I was crazy. And now? With my brother’s record out there? People are going to believe her.”
She was right. The comments on the news articles were already turning. Like brother, like sister. She probably did make it all up. Gold digger. No wonder the mother-in-law wanted to protect the baby.
Lila called an hour later, her voice frantic. “It’s everywhere. Mom’s lawyer gave an exclusive to The Post. He’s saying you drugged Ryan, that you manipulated him into showing the video, that the whole thing was a carefully orchestrated plot to take over the company. He’s also saying you threatened to kill Caleb if he didn’t give you the codes to the family accounts. And the worst part? Dr. Voss is testifying before the family court judge this afternoon. She’s asking for an emergency order to remove Liam from your care. The hearing is at two.”
Claire looked at the clock. It was already ten-thirty. They had less than four hours.
“Who’s the judge?” she asked.
“Judge Harding,” Lila said. “He’s been on the bench twenty years. Super conservative. Hates women with criminal relatives. Mom’s been donating to his re-election campaign for a decade. This is bad, Claire. Really bad.”
Ryan was already on his feet, grabbing his keys. “I’ll call our lawyer. We’ll —”
“No,” Claire said, stopping him. “We can’t use the family lawyer. He works for Margaret. We can’t use any lawyer who’s ever worked for the Whitmores. They all have ties to her. We need someone she can’t buy. Someone who hates her.”
She thought for a second. And then she smiled.
“I know exactly who to call.”
The woman’s name was Victoria Price. She was fifty-two years old, had never lost a custody case in her career, and had spent the last twenty years making it her personal mission to destroy Margaret Whitmore. Ten years earlier, Margaret had stolen Victoria’s husband — a prominent real estate developer — and then ruined his business when he got bored of her and tried to go back to Victoria. Victoria had lost everything: her house, her savings, her reputation. She’d rebuilt from scratch, becoming the most feared family law attorney in the city, and she’d been waiting for a chance to get even ever since.
Claire found her number in the encrypted drive, buried in a folder labeled ENEMIES OF MARGARET. She’d compiled it over the last year, making a list of every person Margaret had ever wronged. She’d known they might come in handy.
Victoria answered on the first ring.
“Claire Bennett,” she said, before Claire could even speak. “I was wondering when you’d call. I’ve been watching the news. Margaret finally overplayed her hand, didn’t she?”
“I need your help,” Claire said, getting straight to the point. “Margaret has a fake psychiatric file on me. She’s got a bought-and-paid-for doctor testifying against me this afternoon at two. She’s asking for emergency custody of my son. The judge is in her pocket. And my brother’s criminal record is all over the news. I’m losing. And I know you’re the only person who can help me win.”
Victoria was quiet for a beat. “What’s in it for me?”
“Margaret,” Claire said simply. “Everything I have on her. The embezzlement. The hospital video. The evidence about Richard’s death. I will hand it all to you. You can use it in the custody case. You can use it to destroy her reputation. You can use it to put her in prison for the rest of her life. Whatever you want. All I ask is that you help me keep my son.”
Another pause. Then Victoria laughed, a low, dangerous sound.
“Send me everything you have,” she said. “I’ll meet you at my office in an hour. And Claire? Tell Ryan to bring his checkbook. This is going to be expensive. But it’s going to be worth every penny. Because I have been waiting ten years to watch Margaret Whitmore lose everything. And today is the day.”
They spent the next three hours in Victoria’s office, going over every detail. Victoria was brilliant — ruthless, sharp, creative. She read the fake psychiatric file in two minutes and threw it across the room.
“Amateur hour,” she scoffed. “Margaret paid Voss fifty grand for this garbage? I can tear it apart in cross-examination. The dates don’t line up. The handwriting on the ‘patient notes’ doesn’t match Voss’s known samples from other cases. And there’s no record of any payment from you to Voss, no insurance claims, no pharmacy records for the medications she claims she prescribed. It’s a joke. Any competent judge would throw it out. Unfortunately, Harding is in her pocket. So we need something bigger. Something that will make him too afraid to rule against us.”
She looked at Claire.
“You said you have evidence Margaret may have killed her husband. How solid is it?”
“Circumstantial,” Claire admitted. “The medical records. The receipt for the medication. The coroner being on the payroll. The insurance policy. No smoking gun. No witness.”
“Good enough,” Victoria said, grinning like a shark. “We don’t need to prove it beyond a reasonable doubt. This is family court. Preponderance of the evidence. We just need to plant the seed. Make Harding think that if he grants Margaret custody, and then it comes out that she murdered her own husband, his career is over. Judges care about one thing more than anything else: their legacy. We make him choose between Margaret and his reputation? He’ll choose his reputation every time.”
She stood, straightening her blazer.
“Now. About your brother. We don’t deny it. We own it. We frame it as a story of redemption. You came from a broken home, you worked three jobs to put yourself through college, you became a forensic accountant, you tried to help your brother but he made his own choices. It shows strength. It shows resilience. It shows you know how to recognize bad decisions and make better ones for your own child. And then we turn it back on Margaret. Your Honor, Mrs. Whitmore is trying to paint my client as dangerous because of something her brother did when he was nineteen. But Mrs. Whitmore is the one who assaulted a woman hours after she gave birth. Mrs. Whitmore is the one who tried to steal a baby. Mrs. Whitmore is the one under investigation for embezzlement and potentially murder. Who is the real danger here?”
She checked her watch.
“Court in forty minutes. Let’s go make Margaret regret the day she ever decided to mess with us.”
As they walked out of the office, Claire’s phone buzzed. It was a text from an unknown number.
She’s not the only enemy you need to worry about. Look at the Whitmore Group board meeting agenda for tomorrow. Item 7.
Claire frowned, forwarding the text to Ryan. He pulled up the agenda on his phone. And then he swore, long and loud.
Item 7: Vote to remove Ryan Whitmore as CEO, effective immediately. Temporary replacement: Margaret Whitmore.
“Even in jail,” Ryan said, shaking his head, “she’s still running the company. She called in favors. The old guard on the board — they’ve been with her since my dad died. They’re scared of her. They’ll vote her back in. And if she gets control of the company again? She’ll have unlimited money to fight us. She’ll drag this out for years. She’ll tie us up in court until Liam is in college.”
Claire looked at the text again. Who would send this? Someone on the inside. Someone who wanted Margaret gone too.
May you like
The enemy of my enemy, she thought. Is my friend.
At least for now.